Barbara-syllogisme

Leren

Het meest fundamentele geldige syllogisme: Alle A zijn B, Alle B zijn C, dus Alle A zijn C.

Barbara is the first and most fundamental of the valid categorical syllogisms identified by Aristotle. It belongs to the first figure and uses universal affirmative (A) propositions in all three positions. The name 'Barbara' comes from medieval mnemonic devices where the three 'a' vowels indicate that all three propositions are universal affirmatives.

All M are P, All S are M ⊢ All S are P

• All mammals are animals. All dogs are mammals. Therefore, all dogs are animals.
• All squares are rectangles. All rectangles are polygons. Therefore, all squares are polygons.
• All physicians are college graduates. All surgeons are physicians. Therefore, all surgeons are college graduates.

Zo herkent u het

• Look for two premises that both use 'All' (universal affirmatives)
• The middle term appears as subject in one premise and predicate in another
• The conclusion links the two end terms with 'All'

Veelgemaakte fouten

• Confusing Barbara with invalid forms like 'All A are B, All C are B, therefore All A are C' (undistributed middle)
• Reversing the chain direction

Oefenadvies

Logische Deductie